Friday, March 28, 2008

Using INNODB_FILE_PER_TABLE

DBAs are always try to determine the best way to manage their storage for InnoDB. The three main options include:
  1. Having one shared InnoDB tablespace data file.
  2. Setting up individual files per InnoDB table.
  3. Setting up a shared tablespace across multiple files.
Option 1: Having one shared InnoDB tablespace data file.
This is fine if you have a simple and small MySQL database. Great for new DBAs to get comfortable with managing MySQL storage.

Option 2: Setting up individual files per InnoDB table.
I like this option when I need to create large transaction tables. This option works well with partitioned objects. Separating your core tables offers more flexibility in administration, backup and recovery and from a storage perspective makes good common sense. I however, do not like using this for all of my InnoDB tables. The more individual files I have to manage the more a DBA will get nickel and dimed from an administration perspective.

Option 3: Setting up a shared tablespace across multiple files.
I like this option because this gives me more flexibility in separating out my I/O if I do not have a storage array doing the striping for me. This allows me to get a lot of my core tables and separate them from other tables by defining their storage in separate data files where I control their location by defining the path of the tablespace data files.

Obviously having a storage array that does your striping and mirroring makes disk I/O management for databases a lot easier. :)

Tuesday, March 25, 2008

Top Ten DBA Interview Questions

I'm often asked what interview questions should be asked of a new DBA you are considering to hire. Mistakes in a DBA hire can cost an organization a lot of money and hurt morale. There are a lot of factors that determine how well a DBA will fit into an environment. I thought I would share some of the things I consider when I interview a new DBA. These questions can be asked to any type of DBA (MySQL, Oracle, SQL Server, DB2, ..).

Questions you have to answer for yourself before interviewing a new DBA include:
  • What skill sets are you looking for in a DBA? What skills are need to have and which are nice to have?
  • How much time do they have to get up to speed?
  • How important is it you hire the right person? (Or what investment are you willing to make to hire the right person).
When interviewing a potential new DBA it is important to understand:
  • What is their technical depth and experience.
  • What type of environments have they worked in.
  • How well do they interact with customers.
  • How well will they fit in to the team and the company environment.
  • What techniques and methodologies do they use to manage databases.
  • How will they impact the current database management practices.
The type of DBA you are trying to hire greatly impacts how you interview the candidates. I don't care to ask a lot of syntax questions or a lot of technical minutia. I want to understand:
  • The depth and breadth of their knowledge.
  • Their methodology and approach to managing databases.
  • How they solve problems.
  • Their commitment and work ethic.
I could write a white paper on explaining the rationale behind each of these questions, but I'll cut to the quick and give a ten step process to interview a new DBA candidate. These questions assume you are looking for a production DBA. If your organization is new and you do not have the expertise to hire the right candidate, you need to hire a consultant that can help your organization through this process.
  1. What are four errors found in an alert (error) log that can ruin a DBA's appetite and how does the candidate avoid them?
  2. What are four performance bottlenecks that can occur in a database server and how are they detected?
  3. Ask them to explain their philosophy for database management and how they implement best practices and guidelines. This should include questions related to the configuration you are running (replication, cluster, OLTP, data warehouse, etc.).
  4. What area of database internals do they understand the best that helps them troubleshoot problems. Ask them to explain this area so you can get an understanding of their depth of knowledge in this area.
  5. Get ten common types of trouble tickets DBAs have solved in your organization and ask them how they would solve them.
  6. Get five difficult problems your DBAs have had to solve and ask them how they would solve them.
  7. Ask them to explain five things they have learned recently that makes them a better DBA and where they learned them.
  8. Set up a simple database environment. Ask them to use two different methods to back up the database. Break the database. Have them recover the database using the backups they created.
  9. Ask them to give a detailed explanation of setting up an environment for disaster recovery or an upgrade for an important database.
  10. Have them write or build a few things in the sample database to demonstrate their knowledge and experience. This should include typical tasks they will be expected to perform to manage the environment.

I like a three or four interview process. Each interview should only leave the candidates that meet the profile of the type of person you want to hire.
  • First interview I like to get a baseline if they match the resume they sent and do they meet the profile of what you are looking for.
  • Second interview I like to make very technical to see if they meet the technical profile of what you are looking for. Make sure you make this sufficiently in-depth for the position you are hiring. There should be no doubt at the end of this interview as to whether they have the technical skills or not for the position you have open.
  • Third interview I like different members of the team determine how well they will fit into your environment and then perform one more level of technical evaluation to make sure you have the right candidate.
Have fun and good luck. What are some of your favorite questions?

Sunday, March 23, 2008

Setting up Apache and PHP on Mac OS Leopard

Apache is a fairly straight forward setup if you use some utility or distribution to help you. A manual installation will take more time. You can Google installation instructions or use a utility like XAMPP to simplify the installation. XAMPP is a distribution that will walk you through an Apache, MySQL, PHP, phpMyAdmin installation. Once you get comfortable with XAMPP these software components can be installed on a Linux or Windows platform in a few minutes.

I'm running Mac OS (Leopard) which comes with a built-in Apache web server (2.2.6) and PHP (5.2.4) preinstalled. On Mac OS (Leopard), perform the following steps to get the Apache Web Server (AWS) and PHP up and running in minutes.
  1. Go to System Preferences. Under Internet and Network select the Sharing icon.
  2. Select the checkbox under Web Sharing. It will return your computer's website URL (IP address or host name) (i.e. http://xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx/). This will also start AWS.
  3. Open up a browser and type your computer's website URL displayed in the Web Sharing page in System Preferences. After typing this URL in a browser. You should get a browser page that shows you your Apache web server is up and running. This is too cool. Mac OS's built in Apache web server takes just a few clicks to have Apache up and running.
  4. Once you've confirmed the Apache web server is up and running, type the httpd -V command to get information on your Apache installation.
Running httpd -V.
$ httpd -V

The httpd -V command returns important information
  • The Apache Web Server version you are running.
  • The location of the Apache configuration file (httpd.conf).
  • The location of the access and error log file.
  • Apache configuration options.
Example snippet of output from the httpd -V command:
Server version: Apache/2.2.6 (Unix)
-D SERVER_CONFIG_FILE="/private/etc/apache2/httpd.conf"
-D DEFAULT_ERRORLOG="logs/error_log"

With Mac OS (Leopard) you can find the access_log and error_log files in the following location:
/private/var/log/apache2/

Turn on PHP 5 on Leopard by uncommenting the following line in your httpd.conf file using a text editor.
# LoadModule php5_module libexec/apache2/libphp5.so

AWS needs to be stopped and restarted for the changes to take effect. Starting and stopping the AWS can be done through the System Preferences | Sharing window. Clicking the Web Sharing checkbox can be used to stop and start Apache. Restart the Apache Web Server so the configuration changes take effect.

Create a PHP configuration file. Then change the error reporting option to display all errors. Instructions:
$ cd /private/etc
$ sudo cp php.ini.default php.ini
$ sudo vi php.ini
Change the error reporting line using vi or a text editor to display all error messages.
error_reporting = E_ALL & -E_NOTICE
error_reporting = E_ALL

Test your PHP configuration
  1. In a browser type your computer's website displayed in the Sharing page. This should launch Safari and display an Apache web page.
  2. Create a page called test.php (lots of examples on Google). Save it in the directory Macintosh HD:Library:WebServer:Documents.
  3. Go to your browser and type your computer URL with a test php (lots on Google) program. If you get the PHP info your configuration is working.
http://xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx/test.php


Apache and PHP should now be up and running on your Mac. Have fun!

Saturday, March 22, 2008

Sun - A very positive beginning

During the last month, I have had the opportunity to be involved in three MySQL training classes that have included Sun employees. Without exception, every Sun employee has shown a lot of enthusiasm about the potential for MySQL and Sun. Every Sun employee has gone out of their way to welcome MySQL employees. There have been a lot of excellent discussions on the potential of Sun and MySQL technology and what they potentially can do together. I wish we could have podcast some of these discussions. The sharing of ideas and the collaboration was fantastic. Getting a number of knowledgeable people in database, messaging, identity management, storage, cluster and application server technology in one room and the exchange of ideas was a great experience. Thanks Pedro, Maggie, Walter, Ram, Andrea, Malek, Mitch, Seumas and everyone for all the positive energy and warm welcome!

Next week the Sun on-board process begins for most U.S. MySQL employees. Meeting a number of fantastic people at Sun is definitely a great beginning to the Sun experience.

Sun - A very positive beginning

During the last month, I have had the privilege of being part of three MySQL training classes in a row that have included Sun employees. I can't understate how great the Sun employees have been in welcoming MySQL employees to Sun. Without exception, Sun employees have stated their excitement in the possibilities and potential of MySQL and Sun. It's been great to see how every Sun employee I've met has gone out of their way to make MySQL employees feel part of Sun. To Pedro, Maggie, Walter, Seumas, Mitch and everyone thanks for all the positive energy and the warm welcome!

Next week begins the Sun on boarding process for most U.S. MySQL employees. Meeting a number of great people at Sun is definitely starting the Sun journey on a very positive note.

MySQL, Blade Servers and Storage

When people think of MySQL they normally think of MySQL running across multiple Intel servers running Red Hat, SuSE or Windows. This is great for small and medium sized organizations. However, adding a number of Intel boxes and dealing with heating, electricity, power and storage is not an ideal scenario for larger organizations.

As MySQL grows in popularity, I believe more organizations are going to look at using blade servers and storage arrays to manage MySQL databases. Will Sun put together a solution that can generate enthusiasm for using Sun Blade Servers and Sun storage solutions. It's kind of funny that I say this. With over twenty years of database and Unix administration experience, to me there is no better operating system for running database servers than Solaris. My personal perspective is that since the days of SunOS, Sun Microsystems has by far the "best" operating system for databases. Does that matter in today's world? I'm not sure.

When you look at Solaris compared to Linux, Solaris is by far the better operating system in my humble opinion. Yet, that does not seem to matter. Linux provides the core functionality people are looking for at the fraction of the cost, so Linux is by far more popular. Actually, this is one way MySQL is gaining market share compared to other proprietary databases. MySQL has the core functionality that people want, at a fraction of the cost of proprietary systems. Other database vendors add more and more functionality, yet this new functionality does not impact the growing popularity of MySQL. Cost is not the only reason MySQL and Linux are popular, yet cost is a strong factor in the popularity equation.

Can Sun package a complete solution with MySQL that can excite the IT industry? This may be one of the key questions for 2008.

MySQL Growth in the Database Market

MySQL can be used 64,000 different ways with just about any type of database. Despite this flexibility, here is how I see the growth of MySQL in the database market:
  • Web-based applications are an area of strength for MySQL. MySQL will continue to grow and remain popular in this space.
  • Data Warehousing is the big potential growth area for MySQL. In the next few years it will be very interesting to monitor MySQL in the data warehousing market. Fast reads, large horizontal scalability and strong yet relative low-cost solutions make MySQL ideal for data warehousing.
  • OLTP is an area that MySQL works well in for small and medium sized solutions. MySQL version 6 is where MySQL can grow significantly in the OLTP market. The Falcon (OLTP) storage engine, designed for modern large memory and multi CPU systems, increased on-line functionality and improved high availability offers significant potential for MySQL in the area of OLTP applications. MySQL version 6 will make MySQL more popular in the on-line Internet database market. You can also expect Oracle (InnoDB) and other 3rd party companies to also offer new scalable OLTP storage engines in the next few years.
The future looks bright for MySQL. It's interesting to look at the database market. It is Oracle and MySQL that are growing in popularity that can be used in multiple platforms.
  • DB2 is typically an IBM solution.
  • SQL Server is typically a Microsoft or low-cost simple solution.
  • Oracle and MySQL are the two database solutions that are popular with multi-platform solutions. HP-UX, AIX, Solaris, Red Hat, SuSE , Windows, etc. are all strong and popular solutions for both Oracle and MySQL. It is only Oracle and MySQL that continue to remain popular on multiple platforms.
Oracle will continue to dominate the large aircraft carrier database solutions and the business applications market. SAP will continue to try and use DB2 and SQL Server with their business applications and use Oracle only when they have to.

As for the web-based applications, small/medium data warehousing applications and small/medium OLTP environments, MySQL will continue to grow in popularity.

Data Warehousing - The Next Step for MySQL

MySQL excels as a strong solution for web-based solutions. MySQL’s extremely fast read rates and ability to scale horizontally with replication makes MySQL a popular low cost of ownership platform for web-based applications. The next area I expect MySQL to encounter significant growth is in the data warehousing market. MySQL’s fast reads and horizontal scalability makes it a strong consideration for the following environments:
  • Real Time and Archive Data Warehouses
  • Data Marts
  • Large Reporting Systems (DSS)
There are a number of strong solutions in the area of BI reporting, Analytics and data integration solutions that can be used with MySQL. Using MySQL for a data warehousing solution allows an organization to build small and medium sized data warehouses without the large startup costs of proprietary databases as well as the extremely expensive BI and data integration solutions that come with proprietary databases.

They say the number one reason restaurants fail is not being able to overcome large startup costs. Using MySQL as the database platform for small and medium data warehouses allows an organization to deliver a strong data warehousing solution at a fraction of the cost of proprietary solutions. This is why I expect data warehousing to be an area of significant growth for MySQL databases in the next few years.

Wednesday, March 12, 2008

Important URLs for Sun and MySQL Documentation

MySQL Documentation: dev.mysql.com

Sun Documentation: http://docs.sun.com/app/docs

Zones: http://www.sun.com/bigadmin/content/zones/

Resource Pools: http://docs.sun.com/app/docs/doc/817-1592/6mhahuolg?a=view

ZFS (New File System): http://www.sun.com/software/solaris/ds/zfs.jsp

SMF (Service Management Facility): http://www.oreilly.com/pub/a/sysadmin/2006/04/13/using-solaris-smf.html

Very cool class in San Francisco

It's an incredible privilege to be able to teach other people. I've always found that knowledge is like love. No matter how much you give you always get more back.

I'm teaching a class this week in San Francisco to a very cool group. Students are from all over the world: China, Malaysia, Germany, Spain, Italy, India and the U.S. It is great to have people from all over the world and we all speak the same language, databases. We're all having a lot of fun singing "Kumbaya". :)

So far the top rated restaurants among the class this week include:
  • Colibri
  • House of NanKing
  • Great Eastern Restaurant
  • Sultan
  • Puccini and Pinetti's
  • Magnolia Pub and Brewery

MySQL and Sun

I don't know if Sun still offers those Sun leather jackets, they were pretty cool. I need to figure out how to get one. Sun areas of interest for MySQL DBAs include:
  • Sun Clusters and how they work with MySQL Cluster.
  • MySQL work and Sun Zones.
  • MySQL works and ZFS.
  • SMF.

Books for new MySQL DBAs

















  • These are two books I would highly recommend for new MySQL DBAs. Both are very well written with a nice writing style. I really like the writing style of the person that wrote the Head First SQL class.
    • Head First MySQL
    • MySQL 5.0 Certification Study Guide

    Wednesday, March 5, 2008

    MySQL - An IT Tipping Point

    A ''tipping point'' is a concept, product or idea that becomes a hot commodity that attracts everyone's attention, interest or inspiration. There are always specific reasons and factors that are not easily identifiable why one product becomes a tipping point and others do not. Products not considered a tipping point usually never become a tipping point and ofter never understand why they didn't. There are tons of examples of this. VHS versus Beta, MP3 players versus iPods, Blue Ray versus HD DVD. The list is endless.

    MySQL is "the" hot tipping point product in the IT industry. MySQL is an incredibly popular open source part of the LAMP stack. There are additional open source products like PostgreSQL, MaxDB, Firebird, Ingres, Apache Derby, etc. No database in the industry is creating the buzz, excitement and interest that MySQL does. People can debate the feature/functionality, performance, etc. between the different databases. Make any comparison you want, none of the other databases that are compared to MySQL are going to be the "tipping point" MySQL is.

    MySQL is a very unique organization with employees that believe in disrupting the industry with innovativeness and new ways of doing things. MySQL employees have been raised with the concept of open source, sharing and caring about their contributions to open source. I do not believe their are many companies in the world that have the "global team" concept that MySQL does. I interact with MySQL team members in Sweden and Germany as easily as team members in my home city. It is the uniqueness of the MySQL employees that are creating the tipping point.

    Web 2.0 environments are increasing exponentially in popularity and MySQL is in the center of the storm of this exciting growth. MySQL has the potential to be the center of innovativeness in Sun the way NeXT was the center of innovation in Apple. Sun has a very powerful engine for future growth in MySQL. There is one thing MySQL has that no other database has. It has the tipping point.


    Installing MySQL Administrator on Linux

    Installing the MySQL GUI tools are pretty easy on Linux (Fedora - 2.6.18-1.2798.fc6) but there are a few prerequisites for setting them up. The following listed RPMs are required. I did a google search and then performed a quick download of them.
    • libsigc++20-2.0.6-1.i386.rpm
    • glibmm-2.4.7-1.rhfc3.nr.i386.rpm
    • gtkmm24-2.8.5-1.i386.rpm
    Load the RPMs. MySQL Administor is loaded in /usr/bin by default.
    # rpm -i libsigc++20-2.0.6-1.i386.rpm
    # rpm -i glibmm-2.4.7-1.rhfc3.nr.i386.rpm
    # rpm -i gtkmm24-2.8.5-1.i386.rpm
    # rpm mysql-gui-tools-5.0r12-1fc5.i386.rpm
    # rpm mysql-administrator-5.0r12-1fc5.i386.rpm

    Go to the Desktop Applications Menu and select the Programming Tab. You will see the MySQL Administor Icon. Select this icon and it will startup up MySQL Administrator in a windows environment. Then have fun! :)

    Sunday, March 2, 2008

    MySQL Priority Poll

    This poll did not get a lot of voters but I thought I would post the results to show you the priority of the individuals that did vote.

    Poll: What is your highest priority with MySQL?
    • Performance Tuning 20%
    • Backup and Recovery 20%
    • Monitoring and Management 16 %
    • High Availability 16%
    • Scalability 12%
    • Storage 10%
    • BI and Reporting 3%
    • Business Strategy 3%

    Choosing a MySQL Configuration Strategy

    MySQL configurations cover the range from developers installing a simple MySQL database for a LAMP application to the largest Internet companies using MySQL to deliver web content.
    There are two different profiles that cover this range for installing, configuring and managing MySQL database servers:
    1. Profile 1: Individuals or small organizations that wants to use MySQL to create a simple database for web applications and the LAMP stack.
    2. Profile 2: Individuals or organizations that are looking at creating larger MySQL databases or may be creating a large number of MySQL databases.
    Profile 1:
    For this profile, the person can be a non-DBA. This profile can use the default install using the Windows Installation Manager or the Unix or Linux RPMs. The GUI interfaces will take you through a very simple install. MySQL database servers do not take a lot of resources to run. The template files (my.small, my.medium, my.large) can show startup files that contain larger configurations. This is a simple environment to install and manage. I have seen non-DBAs and developers use this environment for years and it works great for them.

    This type of DBA is typically using some simple GUI interfaces, doing backups with mysqldump and taking a simple approach for managing MySQL databases. MySQL's basic configuration can make it very popular for the small and medium sized organization.

    Profile2:
    This profile involves more complex and larger MySQL databases. This environment often benefits from installing and configuring using best practices. This environment is more successful with someone that has DBA experience or training. Implementing a MySQL environment with the MySQL Optimal Configuration Architecture (MOCA) where a DBA organizes a database for performance, high availability, ease of management becomes important for this environment being successful.

    Dependent on the size and complexity of the MySQL environment, the DBA for this environment may be more concerned with one or more of these areas:
    • How the MySQL servers will be monitored and managed. Using the MySQL Enterprise Monitor, open source monitors or 3rd party monitors becomes important.
    • What backup strategy to use: Snapshots, InnoDB Hot Backup, Replication, etc.
    • High Availability (MySQL cluster, other clustering strategies).
    • How to balance I/O by spreading data across multiple disks, storage arrays, etc.
    • Performance Tuning.
    • The establishment of database standards, guidelines and best practices (MOCA).
    • Change control.
    • Having to much coffee.
    • Managing test, development and production databases. Developing rollout strategies.
    • Security, auditing, Sarbanes-Oxley, COBIT, ITIL.
    • Information Lifecycle Management
    These two profiles show two ends of the spectrum for MySQL database administration.



    Friday, February 29, 2008

    Best Environments for Running MySQL

    Its interesting when you look at MySQL database environments. Extremely popular in the MySQL world is to use commodity hardware and implement the LAMP stack.  Smaller projects and startup companies love this environment.  A simple example, a company needs to set up a web application, they buy some commodity hardware, set up replication and scale horizontally.  Everybody loves this and it works great.

    This environment requires floor space, cooling, electrical outlets, etc.  As new MySQL database servers get built, the environment needs to consider how this database environment will scale.  Organizations may take a step back and start looking at scaling with blade servers or large host systems to run large numbers of MySQL databases.

    Database servers are I/O intensive.  Growing with cheap disks does not always scale with systems that have large I/O requirements.  Striping and mirroring starts to become more important.  So storage scalability and more expensive storage solutions become a consideration as I/O increases.

    It will be interesting as Sun leads MySQL into more enterprise environments how the hardware and scalability strategies will evolve.

    Thursday, February 28, 2008

    Learning MySQL DBA Best Practices

    It is a challenge for new MySQL DBAs to learn best practices for managing database servers. There are no books that teach you everything you need to know. Key knowledge areas new MySQL DBAs need to learn:
    • Best practices for installation and configuration.
    • How to monitor and manage a database.
    • How to monitor for tuning.
    • Best practices for backup/recovery.
    • Best security practices.
    • What audit controls need to be put in place.
    • Disaster planning.
    • Growth projections and scalability planning.
    • Change management.
    Sources I would recommend a new DBA start with:
    • Google - do searches on best DBA practices, etc.
    • Read information on the MySQL Optimal Configuration Architecture (MOCA) and the Optimal Flexible Architecture (OFA - Oracle related). Both give examples of things to consider when planning databases.
    • Go to conferences and download presentations from previous conferences.
    • Find a mentor.
    • Larger environments look at Sarbanes-Oxley, COBIT and ITIL in terms of best practices for managing IT infrastructures. Waters get deep here for new DBAs.
    • http://www.planetmysql.org

    Tuesday, February 19, 2008

    Maximize your ROI at the MySQL Conference

    The MySQL conference is coming up. It's one of highest ROIs you can get for your training dollar. Just like anything else you do that is successful, plan on how you can maximize your attendance at a conference.

    If you don't attend conferences on a regular basis here are a few things you can do to maximize your experience:
    1. Volunteer! Best way to meet new people and feel a part of the conference.
    2. Join! There are often Special Interest Groups (SIGs) or other groups within a conference that try to bring people with common interests together.
    3. Introduce yourself! Try to meet as many people as you can at the conference. Challenge yourself to meet as many people as you can as possible. Ask them questions like: What's the best presentation you've attended so far? Are there any speakers you really like and would recommend to someone new to a conference attend? What area are you focusing on at the conference? A conference is the best way to work on your communication and networking skills. Buy a book on networking and try some of the techniques. If you are new to the conference no one knows you, what do you have to lose? Ask them about what environments they are running? What challenges are they having with their technology?
    4. Attend get togethers! Every conference has breakfast, unconference and birds of a feather meetings and other ways to network. If one doesn't work out, don't get discouraged. Remember you don't know anyone there how can you make a mistake.
    5. Business cards. Bring business cards and everyone you meet give them a business card. Who knows, someone might even give you there card. :)
    6. Prepare! Get organized. There are tons of great books, blogs, and Internet information on 10 ten tips for introducing yourself, networking and socializing. Try them.
    7. Submit! Submit a presentation. Awesome way to expand your comfort level and for people to get to know you. Most important thing people want at a conference is to learn from other people's experiences. You don't have to be a top expert. Do not underestimate what you have to say?
    I consider myself a pretty social person. However, I remember when I first starting going to conferences it was pretty lonely. I wasn't comfortable walking up and talking to people. The first birds of a feather meeting I went to, I walked in the door, everybody looked up at me, I froze and I walked out. I realized I was too shy but was too embarrassed to walk back in. It can get really lonely if it seems everybody else knows each other.

    Since then I have ran different areas of a conference, been on expert panels, given key note presentations and been on board of directors for conferences. All of these things occurred because I was willing to push myself past my comfort zone and began to submit papers for presenting and to join different groups at conferences.

    Networking is always rated first or second in terms of benefits for people that attend conferences. If you would like to increase your networking skills I would recommend you read the book "Million Dollar Networking" by Andrea Nierenberg. This will give you a lot of great ideas, recommendations and things to say to greatly increase your networking skills. You are going to spend thousands of dollars to attend the conference, why not spend another $30 and maximize the networking you can do.

    Everybody attending a conference has been in your shoes. Go introduce yourself to volunteers or speakers. Ask them about ways to maximize the time at the conference and what speakers they like to see. All volunteers I guarantee you want you to have fun and enjoy the conference and they know what its like to go to a conference for the first time. Most importantly, find out if any MySQL instructors are around, they are some of the coolest, most enjoyable and high energetic people you'll find at the conference. :)

    Monday, February 18, 2008

    The Right Strategy for Customers

    There have been significant trends and changes in the IT industry. Some of them include:
    • Main Frame systems
    • Client/Server
    • Distributed systems
    • Multi-tiered platforms with application servers
    • Open Source
    It's important to understand each of these is a technology to help meet business goals. Open source is currently an area of high growth and interest in the industry. The cost benefits provide organizations with a lot of flexibility in how they put their infrastructures together. Global markets and competition are putting even more pressure on IT organizations to make the right decisions.

    I was talking to a friend about what organizations are doing with open source strategies. The result of the conversation ended with it is not about an open source strategy. It is more about developing the "right customer strategy" and if and how open source can play a role in helping a customer meet their business objectives and goals.

    I've always felt as a DBA/manager, the more options I have the better decisions I can make. Including open source solutions in the decision process helps make sure customers are looking at their overall strategy in addressing challenges they are facing. No one technology solution is the best solution for every problem that exists. Oracle Enterprise Edition, Oracle Standard Edition, Oracle Express, MySQL, Oracle Application Server, Apache, JBoss, BEA, Eclipse, JDeveloper, Linux, PHP, Ruby on Rails, etc. all have features that can leverage what customers are trying to do. I have nothing against Windows or IBM it has just been my preference to work with Oracle and MySQL environments. Oracle and BEA have played well in the large enterprise commercial environments. MySQL has played well in Internet and web applications. For anyone to say other vendors do not provide a good solution is pretty closed minded. What I like to do is understand what a customer is trying to do and weigh the pros and cons and let them make the decision that is best for customer.

    Most companies are running different types of applications.
    • Java and SOA are extremely scalable and powerful solutions that are great when those benefits are needed.
    • Ruby on Rails and PHP are great for web based applications that do not need a lot of database features.
    There are current and future costs and ramifications associated with hardware, database, application server and application development decisions. With all the options out there customers need to make sure they align their purchases with their business objectives.

    Trends for DBAs

    I grew up in the old days when the primary tools used to manage databases was Unix shells scripts and my development tool was vi. This was back in the day when if you showed other DBAs a script for monitoring and tuning, they would respond to it the way cavemen would look at fire. Those days are long gone.

    Whether it is open source, vendor or 3rd party tools DBAs need to use software to help them manage their environments. Whatever the tool: Nagios, Mon, Zenoss, Cacti, MySQL Enterprise Monitor, etc. it is important to use tools to manage a database environment. In the monitoring and management side this includes the entire infrastructure which includes the application server and applications environment. As a DBA it is very important to be in a proactive environment where the administration infrastructure is scalable as more database instances and database schemas are added to the environment. The negative ramifications of using scripts and not software to monitor and manage a database environment include:
    • The more manual scripts (Unix, Perl, etc.) the more you are building a high maintenance environment that has to be supported.
    • As your environment changes with different software, application servers, applications, etc the more the scripts need to be modified.
    • New DBAs usually will not want to bet their jobs on someone else's scripts. Working scripts often get thrown away by new DBAs which will replace existing scripts with their own scripts.
    • Manual scripts are not as scalable as using software.
    • Using manual scripts are not cost-effective compared to using software for monitoring and management.
    • Manual scripts are more error-prone than using software.
    • Manual script environments are usually more reactive versus proactive. Reactive environments are not conducive to high availability.
    Companies are looking more for DBAs that can help make strategic decisions, understand the business, have strong communication and management skills and understand how to manage databases from an enterprise perspective. This is different that the traditional heads down, perform technical tasks and write scripts type of DBA.

    Sunday, February 17, 2008

    Leveraging MySQL Environments for Scalability

    One of the biggest mistakes organizations make when they look at MySQL, they look at just the MySQL Database Server. There are a lot of tools available in MySQL environments that can offer tremendous scalability to MySQL database servers while keeping the total cost of ownership down. Some of my favorites include:
    • Memcache - Memcache is a high performance distributed caching system. This offers tremendous benefits to dynamic web appliations. This caching system can take large loads off the database server and distribute across low-cost servers with a global cache. Most large scale MySQL database environments use memcache.
    • Replication - MySQL replication supports the distribution of MySQL across multiple low cost servers. Replication can be implemented with no additional license fees.
    • LAMP - Linux, Apache, MySQL, PHP/Perl/Python (LAMP) is a low cost proven platform for implementing web applications.
    • Monitoring - Nagios, Mon, Zenoss and Cacti are excellent monitoring tools for MySQL database environments. Zabbix is a product I have not looked at but their website information on their product definitely got my attention. The MySQL Enterprise Monitor is a licensable product but it can be used at a fraction of the cost of other database vendor monitoring tools and 3rd party solutions.


    MySQL Migration Toolkit








    The MySQL Migration Toolkit is a nice easy to use Wizard GUI tool for migrating databases to MySQL. The following site http://www.mysql.com/products/tools/migration-toolkit/ has some really nice tutorials for how to migrate the following databases to MySQL:
    • SQL Server
    • Oracle
    • Access
    The MySQL Migration Toolkit will facilitate the migration of the following database schema objects:
    • Tables
    • Indexes
    • Views
    • Assists with Stored Procedure Migration
    • Assists with Trigger Migration
    Some features that stand out about the MySQL Migration Toolkit:
    • The MySQL Migration Toolkit allows direct server to server migration. The migration tookkit can run remotely.
    • Data can be transfered online or a snapshot of the data can be stored for executing a transfer offline at a later time. A backup can be created of the stored data as well.
    Migrating Access to MySQL
    MySQL is an excellent migration strategy for organizations using Access. Migrating to MySQL provides the following benefits to existing Access environments:
    • Extremely low startup costs.
    • Ability to leverage the LAMP stack and Web 2.0.
    • Portability to major releases of Linux, Unix and Mac OS platforms.
    • Increased operational flexibility from a closed proprietary environment to open source.
    • Significantly increased scalability.
    Migrating SQL Server to MySQL
    MySQL is an excellent migration strategy for organizations using SQL Server. Migrating to MySQL provides the following benefits to existing SQL Server environments:
    • Extremely low startup costs.
    • Ability to leverage the LAMP stack and Web 2.0.
    • Portability to major releases of Linux, Unix and Mac OS platforms.
    • Increased operational flexibility from a closed proprietary environment to open source.
    • Relatively low cost increased scalability compared to SQL Server scalability costs.
    Oracle and MySQL Environments
    I believe Oracle and MySQL play well together more than any other two RDBMS systems.
    • MySQL does well in the small and medium database range and supports the LAMP stack and Web 2.0.
    • For web applications that do not leverage a lot of database features. Using MySQL at the lower end can greatly reduce the total cost of ownership.
    • Oracle and MySQL can play very well together to maximize what a customer needs to do while minimizing cost.
    • Oracle offers tremendous scalability and an incredible amount of features to address complex problems in large organizations.
    • MySQL offers relatively low cost increased scalability compared to Oracle scalability costs. No costs associated with using partitioning and replication. MySQL Cluster is a fraction of the cost of running Oracle RAC.

    Saturday, February 16, 2008

    MySQL and Oracle Parallels

    When I look at the current and future releases of MySQL I see a lot of parallels to Oracle releases. Although MySQL and Oracle have taken different approaches there is a thread of commonality.
    • MySQL 4 and Oracle 6 releases were acceptable releases for their time but their features limited the software from having a larger impact in the database market. I always joke that Oracle Version 6 made Sybase and Oracle 7 along with Sybase 10 helped destroy Sybase.
    • MySQL 5 and Oracle 7 took the database releases so they could take new large steps in the database market.
    • MySQL 6 and Oracle 8 are releases that take the database software for each company to gigantic new levels in terms of scalability and the ability to handle significantly larger systems. In terms of performance, high availability and reduces administration.
    I believe the future of MySQL with version 5 and the upcoming version 6 is very bright.

    MySQL in the Enterprise

    In the last few months MySQL has taken serious steps to have it play a larger role in the enterprise. For MySQL to take the next steps the following needs to occur on the technology side:
    • Help customers understand the scalability of MySQL.
    • MySQL needs to expand in the small to medium size data warehouse market. MySQL excels on delivering large volumes of Internet content at high speed. High read rates are what you need to make a data warehouse work. Using MySQL replication, organizations can scale horizontally at inexpensive incremental rates.
    • MySQL needs an inexpensive striping and mirroring storage strategy to help organizations that can't afford an expensive EMC or Veritas solution. Hmmm, I wonder if there is a company out there who could help MySQL's storage strategy? :-)
    • Organizations need to realize there are commercial open source solutions like Pentaho that can deliver business solutions, BI and reporting capabilities in the small and medium sized database environments. There are open source commercial solutions that can help MySQL environments deliver medium sized enterprise solutions. Saving 6 and 7 figures on licensing of software can provide a lot of flexibility in terms of hardware and software options.
    • Organizations new to MySQL need a better understanding of how OS snapshots and InnoDB Hot Backup can be used to provide hot backups in OLTP environments.
    • More MySQL DBAs that have an enterprise perspective. Oracle DBAs are the perfect source. Too many organizations look at MySQL and do not understand how to set it up properly to leverage what it can do.
    • Organizations like Google, Yahoo, YouTube, Flicker, etc. know how to build highly scalable MySQL environments. Products like Memcache can greatly benefit MySQL scalability. Scaling MySQL is still a skill not known to a lot of companies.
    • MySQL and industry analysts need more bench marks on exactly where MySQL reaches it's limit on the OLTP side. The knowledgeable industry expert understands MySQL has proven to deliver high read rates. For customers to feel comfortable using MySQL in more OLTP environments, customers need to understand where MySQL tops out on the OLTP side.

    Pentaho's Bee

    Has anyone else been mesmerized by looking at the bee on Pentaho's website. Something about that bee is pretty interesting. I wish they'd take it further and create a screen saver where you can configure multiple bees on your desktop. I'm not even a bee fan.

    Oracle and MySQL - A winning team

    Oracle is definitely the Mercedes Benz of database servers. We can debate the merits of different databases but in terms of the most features, Oracle definitely stands alone. Excellent high availability features such as RAC, Data Guard and Streams offer excellent enterprise solutions. So for running enterprise business applications such as PeopleSoft, JD Edwards, Siebel and the Oracle EBusiness Suite the Oracle Database Server is in a class by itself.

    When you look at all the applications running in an organization, what percentage are enterprise class applications that require an Oracle database server. I would say the major percentage of applications running in an organization do not need an enterprise database server like Oracle. This is where MySQL plays nice. Heterogeneous environments running Oracle and MySQL will run at a fraction of the costs of running Oracle-SQL Server, Oracle -DB2 or SQL Server-DB2. Also MySQL being a friendly open source company does not bring in the religious issues Oracle DBAs would have with SQL Server or DB2. Some examples of how Oracle and MySQL would be a cost effective solution:
    • Greatly reduced software costs. For example backup and recovery is free in Oracle (Recovery Manager - RMAN). In a heterogeneous environment, a company can buy a great online backup solution such as InnoDB Hot Backup that is roughly $1000 per server. If running Oracle with SQL Server or DB2 the 3rd party backup solutions or vendor add-ons can easily run into six figures.
    • If an organization has already purchased Oracle Grid Control it would be very easy to have Oracle Grid Control monitor MySQL database servers.
    • Oracle SQL Developer could easily support MySQL database environments. Someone told me they got Oracle's SQL Developer to hook into MySQL easily. I'll have to try and find time to test this.
    • Oracle JDeveloper can deploy into JBoss environments and other open source application servers.
    • Oracle's stored procedure language PL/SQL is very close in syntax to MySQL's stored routine language. You could easily write a parser in Perl that would address most of the syntax differences.
    If I could ask Larry one question it would be if he regrets not trying to go after MySQL. I wonder if the Oracle acquisition team was so focused on the business applications market they did not look into the database market as closely as they should have. If Oracle had purchased MySQL could a strategy have been developed to use MySQL to keep SQL Server out of the lower end database market. Would the purchase price of MySQL have generated a significant ROI to justify the purchase by being able to help keep SQL Server out of Oracle's lower end market? Hmmm. Too bad, I guess we'll never know.

    Understanding the Total Cost of Ownership for Databases















    Vendors often talk about the Total Cost of Ownership (TCO). A MySQL environment offers significantly reduced overall costs and greatly reducing the total cost of ownership. When purchasing a database companies look at the license numbers of the database but often underestimate the surrounding costs of running a particular database. Overall TCO also includes the following costs:
    • Hardware
    • Application Servers
    • GUI development tools
    • Monitoring tools
    • Administration costs
    • 3rd party software
    • Technical skills
    • Scalability
    MySQL offers a TCO that is a fraction of other database vendors. The following are some examples of how the costs of running a MySQL environment are significantly reduced:
    • Hardware: MySQL database servers take significantly less hardware resources compared to Oracle DB2 or SQL Server. There is also more flexibility in choosing Windows, Linux, Unix or Mac OS platforms.
    • Application Servers: MySQL environments usually use Apache or JBoss run at a fraction of the costs of running application servers from IBM, Oracle, BEA and Microsoft.
    • Monitoring Tools: MySQL environments use tools like Nagios, Mon, Zenoss, Cacti are free or a fraction of the costs compared to vendor or 3rd party tools that often have licenses in the 6 and 7 figure range.
    • GUI Development Tools: MySQL environments often run SQLYog, Navicat, MySQL Query Browser that are free or run at a fraction of the cost of 3rd party tools for the larger database vendors.
    • GUI Admin Tools: MySQL Administrator, phpMyAdmin and Enterprise Monitor are free or run at a fraction of the cost of 3rd party tools for the larger database vendors.
    • BI and Reporting: BI Open Source tools from companies like Pentaho run at a fraction of the costs of BI solutions from the major vendors.
    • Scalability: Features like partitioning and replication are free in MySQL. So as your environment grows there are no additional license costs. MySQL Cluster is a licensable feature but it also is a fraction of the clustering solutions from the larger database vendors. Database servers are going to grow, so its great to know that a MySQL environment allows you to use free features or features that do not have large incremental increases the larger your databases grow.
    When looking at a database vendor make sure and consider the overall Total Cost of Ownership and not just the costs of running a database server.

    Database Market Share


    Mark Twain once said, "Figures often beguile me, particularly when I have the arranging of them myself; in which case the remark attributed to Disraeli would often apply with justice and force: "There are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies and statistics."



    Whenever I look at statistics and numbers I not only take them with a grain of salt but I also try to understand how they arrived at the numbers. When you look at the analyst's reports on the top database vendors it is often based on total revenue or licensable revenue. So how does open source numbers come into play. The same industry analyst's that show MySQL as having very small market share based on revenue also state estimates of between 8 - 10 million MySQL instances are currently running. Analysts also estimate MySQL binaries are downloaded 40 - 50 thousand times a day.

    MySQL is encountering incredible growth but the growth is often hidden in the way numbers are collected. There is a lot of momentum and energy around open source, it will be interesting to see how the industry analysts use numbers to track this growth.

    Friday, February 15, 2008

    George Trujillo at RMOUG Oracle Conference in Denver

    I attended the RMOUG Oracle Users Conference in Denver, CO this week. RMOUG is an excellent local Oracle users group conference to attend. I delivered a presentation on:

    Understanding the MySQL Architecture for Oracle DBAs
    • This is a fast paced presentation focused on showing Oracle DBAs and Developers key features and benefits of using MySQL and the LAMP stack for projects. Topics will focus on: best practices for configuring a MySQL database server, understanding key differences between Oracle and MySQL and OFA versus MOCA. Attendees will also be introduced to MySQL replication and Cluster configurations. This is an excellent bootstrap presentation for developers and DBAs that may be looking at using MySQL and the LAMP stack for future projects.
    • Audience: Developers and DBAs
    • Summary: A bootstrap presentation focused on showing Oracle DBAs and developers key features of MySQL and the LAMP stack.
    I delivered it entirely from an Oracle perspective, using Oracle examples and it was very well received. I love delivering this presentation because I always get some great comments from Oracle DBAs who are really surprised how much MySQL can do. I show them MySQL replication and I alway get at least a couple of wows.

    I also delivered the following presentation:

    Demystifying Middleware Technologies
    • This presentation is designed to demystify popular Middleware technologies and explain how these technology components work together. Topics include: J2EE, Application Servers, Web Services, XML, Application Frameworks, WSDL, BPEL, SOA and business rule engines. Attendees will learn how each of these different Middleware components work together in application servers. This is an important presentation for developers and DBAs who would like to learn more about the middle-tier.
    I'm very comfortable in the Java and SOA world so I had a lot of fun with this presentation. Not sure why, I delivered the first presentation with energy and fire and the second presentation as a fire side chat. It may have been due to the high octane coffee I had at the coffee stand in the Colorado Convention center. :)

    Wednesday, January 30, 2008

    Partitioning a Powerful Tool for DBAs

    Partitioning tables and indexes in a database is one of the most powerful features that can help the performance and manageability of a database with large tables. With a large database, there are usually only a handful of very large tables. These large tables typically get most of the I/O activity and have the biggest impact on performance and management.

    Partitioning tables and indexes breaks a big problem (large tables) into a number of smaller manageable pieces (table partitions). When a table is partitioned, it is broken into separate physical chunks of data (partitions). For example, there is a large sales table with 10 million records. When generating a monthly or quarterly report, enough records are accessed so an index scan is not efficient, so a full table scan has to be performed. So every month more records get added to the table and every month the monthly report takes longer to run because it is generating a full table scan to go through the data.

    An example of how partitioning can have an impact: a sales table can be divided into partitions (i.e. monthly increments) based on the sales date (partition key). So one table partition will have January's data, another partition can have February's data and so on. When a monthly report is generated, an I/O scan will occur on one month of data instead of the entire table. The table partitioning is transparent to the applications. While processing the SQL statement, the optimizer understands the table is partitioned and checks to see if individual partitions can be scanned instead of the entire table.

    Partition Pruning
    Partition pruning allows a query to run on specific partitions instead of an entire table. Leveraging this benefit requires understanding the data and how the data is accessed to determine the best partitioning method and what column(s) should be the partition key. The partition key is the column(s) used to divide the data into separate partitions. Sufficient time needs to be spent determining the correct column(s) to define as the partition key and defining the correct partition type for the table.

    Partitioning offers a number of advantages:
    • Partition pruning allows I/O to be performed on smaller data sets instead of the entire table. As tables grow larger, it can be a big advantage to perform partition scans.
    • Being able to perform administration operations at the partition level versus the table level. This can decrease maintenance times and improve availability.
    • Partitioning is transparent at the application level. Applications (SQL and stored procedure code) will not be impacted by going to a partitioning solution. The optimizer will consider partition pruning (selecting individual partitions) during the optimization phase of processing a SQL command if the partition key column(s) is used in the WHERE clause.
    • Supports information lifecycle management so as data gets older it can be truncated or deleted in older partitions and not impact the more current partitions.
    • Partitioning on indexes breaks one big index into smaller indexes which can significantly reduce I/O on the indexes.
    Some examples of using partitioning:
    Here are two examples where partitioning can have a positive impact.
    1. A key transaction table is expected to grow by 30% over the next year. It may not be acceptable for the I/O performance to decrease as more data is added to a table. Being able to internally break a table into separate chunks of data that contain data for an individual month or region can offer significant advantages. Monthly reports or regional reports can perform partition scans on specific months or regions and not have to perform full table scans.
    2. A table needs to store data for 13 months. Every month when the oldest partition expires it can be truncated instead of going through and deleting all the old records that have expired.
    Different types of partitioning
    Range or list partitioning is good to use when there are recognized patterns for how the data is accessed or organizing the data into defined data sets makes sense from an administration perspective. Hash and key partitioning is good to use when someone is just as likely to access one record as another or there is not a clear recognized way to divide the data but there are so many records in a table the benefits of partitioning can be leveraged.
    * RANGE
    * LIST
    * HASH
    * KEY
    * Composite partitioning- RANGE AND LIST partitions can be sub-partitioned by HASH or KEY.
    - RANGE-HASH
    - RANGE-KEY
    - LIST-HASH
    - LIST-KEY

    Code examples:
    In this example, we have selected the sdate column as the partition key. The table will be broken into separate data chunks (partitions) based on the VALUES LESS THAN clause. Here we have stated that all data before January 1, 2008 will go in the first partition. Partition ranges are not inclusive. Which means Partition Jan2008 will store records where the sdate value is 2008-01-01 or greater and less than 2008-02-01. For 2008 the data is broken into monthly increments. The partition key is defined by the columns listed in the partition clause. The values in the partition key columns determine which partitions the records will be put in.

    Range Example:
    Range partition example has one partition for dates before 2008 and monthly partitions after that. The MAXVALUE keyword will accept any records with a sales date that is 2008-04-01 or greater. Once we get into May, a new partition for the new month can be created.
    CREATE TABLE sales (
    invoice_id INT NOT NULL AUTO_INCREMENT,
    sdate DATE NOT NULL,
    samt DECIMAL (10,2) UNSIGNED NOT NULL,
    region_id INT (3),
    cust_id INT,
    INDEX ( invoice_id),
    INDEX ( sdate) ) ENGINE=innodb
    PARTITION BY RANGE (to_days(sdate)) (
    PARTITION before2008 VALUES LESS THAN (to_days('2008-01-01')) ,
    PARTITION Jan2008 VALUES LESS THAN (to_days('2008-02-01')) ,
    PARTITION Feb2008 VALUES LESS THAN (to_days('2008-03-01')) ,
    PARTITION Mar2008 VALUES LESS THAN (to_days('2008-04-01')) ,
    PARTITION plast VALUES LESS THAN MAXVALUE );

    List Example:
    List partition example partitions based on the region_id column. The value for the region_id will determine which partition the data goes into.
    CREATE TABLE sales (
    invoice_id INT NOT NULL AUTO_INCREMENT,
    sdate DATE NOT NULL,
    samt DECIMAL (10,2) UNSIGNED NOT NULL,
    region_id INT (3),
    cust_id INT,
    INDEX ( invoice_id),
    INDEX ( region_id) ) ENGINE=myisam
    PARTITION BY LIST (region_id) (
    PARTITION North VALUES IN (1, 2, 5, 6),
    PARTITION South VALUES IN (7,8,15,16 ),
    PARTITION West VALUES IN (20, 21, 22, 23, 24),
    PARTITION East VALUES IN (30, 31, 32, 34, 35) );

    Hash example:
    Hash table example generates 16 partitions that will be used to try and evenly divide the data. Hash partitioning uses the modulus operator to distribute the data.
    CREATE TABLE download(
    id INT NOT NULL,
    pname VARCHAR(60),
    ddate DATE NOT NULL,
    pcode INT,
    region_id INT ) ENGINE=myisam
    PARTITION BY HASH(region_id)
    PARTITIONS 16;

    Key partition example:
    Key table table breaks the data into 16 partitions. With key partitioning, the MySQL server will use an internal algorithm to try to evenly distribute the data.
    CREATE TABLE download(
    id INT NOT NULL,
    pname VARCHAR(60),
    ddate DATE NOT NULL,
    pcode INT,
    region_id INT ) ENGINE=innodb
    PARTITION BY KEY (id)
    PARTITIONS 16;

    Composite Partitioning
    If the number of records that go into a range or list partition are still too too big, then a composite partitioning can be performed. Range or list partitioned tables can have a lower level of partitioning performed. This is called sub partitioning.

    RANGE-HASH partitioning
    This RANGE-HASH partitioning will have four has subpartitions for every range.
    CREATE TABLE sales (
    invoice_id INT NOT NULL AUTO_INCREMENT,
    sdate DATE NOT NULL,
    samt DECIMAL (10,2) UNSIGNED NOT NULL,
    region_id INT (3),
    cust_id INT,
    INDEX ( invoice_id),
    INDEX ( sdate) ) ENGINE=innodb
    PARTITION BY RANGE (to_days(sdate))
    SUBPARTITION BY HASH( region_id)
    SUBPARTITIONS 4(
    PARTITION before2008 VALUES LESS THAN (to_days('2008-01-01')) ,
    PARTITION Jan2008 VALUES LESS THAN (to_days('2008-02-01')) ,
    PARTITION Feb2008 VALUES LESS THAN (to_days('2008-03-01')) ,
    PARTITION Mar2008 VALUES LESS THAN (to_days('2008-04-01')) ,
    PARTITION plast VALUES LESS THAN MAXVALUE );

    This RANGE-HASH partition table defines the number of subpartitions to be defined for each range. Different numbers of subpartitions can be defined when different months can have different volumes of sales. So it may be necesssary for some some ranges to have a larger or smaller number of partitions.

    CREATE TABLE sales (
    invoice_id INT NOT NULL AUTO_INCREMENT,
    sdate DATE NOT NULL,
    samt DECIMAL (10,2) UNSIGNED NOT NULL,
    region_id INT (3),
    cust_id INT,
    INDEX ( invoice_id),
    INDEX ( sdate) ) ENGINE=innodb
    PARTITION BY RANGE (to_days(sdate))
    SUBPARTITION BY HASH( region_id) (
    PARTITION before2008 VALUES LESS THAN (to_days('2008-01-01'))
    ( SUBPARTITION s0,
    SUBPARTITION s1 ),
    PARTITION Jan2008 VALUES LESS THAN (to_days('2008-02-01'))
    ( SUBPARTITION s3,
    SUBPARTITION s4 ),
    PARTITION Feb2008 VALUES LESS THAN (to_days('2008-03-01'))
    ( SUBPARTITION s5,
    SUBPARTITION s6 ),
    PARTITION Mar2008 VALUES LESS THAN (to_days('2008-04-01'))
    ( SUBPARTITION s7,
    SUBPARTITION s8,
    SUBPARTITION s9,
    SUBPARTITION s10),
    PARTITION plast VALUES LESS THAN MAXVALUE
    (SUBPARTITION s11,
    SUBPARTITION s12)
    );

    To leverage partition pruning, the partition key column (sdate) needs to be in a WHERE clause, for the optimizer to consider performing partition scans. For example, the following query will only access data that is in the Jan2008 instead of the full table. So if we use the partition key in the WHERE clause then monthly and quarterly reports will perform partition scans and not full table scans.

    SELECT * FROM sales
    WHERE sdate BETWEEN '2008-01-01' AND '2008-01-01';

    A few points about partitioning in MySQL 5.1
    This is the first release of partitioning in MySQL so the focus is on key features of partitioning. It's a little tough due to some of the restrictions (listed below) but they are offset by the fact that MySQL offers partitioning for free. This can be an expensive license for other database vendors. This allows MySQL users the ability to leverage the great benefits of partitioning without any additional licensing costs.

    People always ask me how big should a table be before we start considering partitioning. I then give my favorite answer, "it depends". Once a table gets to the size that the following become issues, it is time to consider partitioning:
    • Full tables scans are too expense.
    • Maintenance operations on an entire table take too long.
    • Availability is being impacted by the table being too large.
    • ILM can be leveraged by going to partitioning.

    Some restrictions of using partitioning in MySQL 5.1
    • Partitioned tables must be partitioned on the partition key using an integer or must contain an expression that evaluates to an integer expression (key partitioning is an exception to this). Partition pruning can still be performed on date columns if you use the TO_DAYS() or YEAR() functions.
    • There can be a maximum of 1024 partitions.
    • Foreign keys are not supported.
    • If a table contains a primary key, the columns in the partition key must be part of the primary key.

    Monday, January 28, 2008

    Don't Underestimate MySQL

    A lot of the popularity of MySQL is its ease of installation and how easy it is to use out of the box. Anyone can install MySQL pretty easily. That is the danger of MySQL. Because MySQL is so easy to install, people can forget or not realize that MySQL is a full blown database server. MySQL:
    • Needs to be installed properly.
    • Needs to be tuned like any other database server the more it is used.
    • Proper management practices need to be put in place.
    I've taught the Oracle 10g DBA Workshop I and the MySQL Database Administration classes. I will tell you that the MySQL DBA class is every bit as technical and complex as the Oracle DBA class. The point is there is a lot to learn about MySQL if you are going to use it in a production environment. As a MySQL DBA you are going to have to configure, tune and manage MySQL as a database server similar to how other database servers are managed. MySQL's performance, scalablity, security and ease of administration are dependent on how MySQL is configured.

    The most common mistake I see among DBAs that come from other database vendor environments is that they underestimate how much MySQL can be configured and that its architecture and tools are different than other databases. Storage engines, sql modes, MySQL memory caches and buffers, SQL and PL/SQL processing, replication, etc. all need to be understood to maximize how MySQL can be used. Even the hardware purchases are different in a MySQL environment.

    MySQL is growing in popularity as an enterprise solution. So if you are an Oracle, SQL Server, DB2, Sybase, Informix DBA, do not underestimate how much you can do with MySQL. If you are going to manage MySQL databases in a production environment you should be taking the DBA, Performance Tuning and High Availability classes to learn the core fundamentals of MySQL.

    Monday, January 21, 2008

    Stored Procedures in MySQL

    Stored procedures were introduced in the MySQL database server in version 5.0. It has been interesting to see the growth of stored procedures in the MySQL community because it is completely different with how stored procedures grew in the Oracle community.

    Stored Procedures in Oracle
    Stored procedures were introduced in Oracle 7, back in the client/server glory days. DBAs and developers using Oracle Forms and Reports seen the immediate benefit of using stored procedures in the database and PL/SQL stored procedures became very popular. A large part of this was due to developers considered themselves "database developers" so they tried to always leverage the features in the database. The PL/SQL language has grown through all the releases of Oracle and now in Oracle 11g Database Server, PL/SQL is still extremely popular and experienced Oracle DBAs and developers find tremendous benefits in writing stored procedures.

    Stored Procedures in MySQL
    I have not seen a great adoption of stored procedures in MySQL. I believe one of the reasons is due to the community of developers writing code for MySQL and open source applications. The core developers who write applications for MySQL are using Perl, Python, Ruby on Rails and PHP. They think first of how to write applications leveraging the benefits of the language they are working with and not the database. They write feature and GUI rich applications that run in the middle tier. So it is not natural for most of they to look and leverage the features in the MySQL database server. As web applications grow larger and access larger data sets this approach can effect performance as applications grow popular.

    Remember the Wisdom of the Ancient Ones
    If you study history or watch the history channel you are probably aware that long time ago, there were a group of ancient ones who had acquired great knowledge that has slowly been lost through the ages. They were called the Main Framers. One of the core beliefs of these ancient ones was that the closer you put your applications to the data the faster they run if they are data intensive. Slowly with the growth of client/server and then multi-tiered applications, this great wisdom has been slowly forgotten over time. There are new generations of developers who now even question if the people known as the Main Framers even really existed or if it is a myth.

    The Benefits of using Stored Procedures
    When writing data intensive algorithms, the most efficient place to run this code is in the database server. Runtime environments leverage the execution of the application code, not the database code. It does not make sense to access data, send it across the network, then filter and massage it in the middle tier application code. It is best to run this data intensive code in the database server, filter it and massage it in the database server and send what needs to be displayed to the middle tier. This approach will reduce network traffic and leverage what the database server and the middle tier each do best.

    Growth of Stored Procedures in MySQL
    Version 5 of MySQL introduced stored procedures with basic functionality. In version 6 of MySQL and future releases you can expect to see a lot of enhancements that will continue to leverage running data intensive code in the database server.

    It would be wise for open source developers to look at how they can filter and massage data in the database server and send to the middle tier only the data they need to process and display for their application.

    MySQL - A change agent for open source




















    The 1st Edition of "The MySQL Story" was handed out during the MySQL meeting in Orlando when the Sun acquisition of MySQL was announced. MySQL is a very cool company with employees that have a very unique, committed and passionate perspective to open source.

    MySQL employees are taught to be "disruptive", to shake the world with new ideas and innovativeness. With a strong believe and commitment to open source, MySQL AB has created a company where everyone believes that there is a greater good that can be accomplished by working together, collaborating together, sharing and freely exchanging ideas. I believe a lot of the great company "team" attitude and commitment to work together is fostered by the belief in open source.

    If Sun truly wants the MySQL acquisition to succeed, I strongly recommend Sun to let the core values of MySQL to survive and to try not to change MySQL but to support MySQL so the MySQL database server can grow better and stronger and help open reach new levels of success. Open success succeeding is a win for every individual and startup company on the Internet.

    I find it interesting all the doomsayers predicting all the things that could go wrong with this MySQL acquisition and can MySQL go head to head with Oracle. You always hear this from the industry analysts never from MySQL employees. Oracle is like an aircraft carrier task force and MySQL is like a small speed boat. All MySQL employees know this and love MySQL being a speed boat. All the doom sayers and preachers of gloom need to relax a little bit or maybe that helps get readers. Open source believers believe in "open source". They are not religious zealots for Ruby on Rails, PHP, MySQL, Linux or any other component of open source. They are committed to open source. MySQL understands as well as any, open source group. I can't predict the future, you will always see MySQL at the front of the battle lines for open source. I suggest everybody sit and wait to see how the MySQL database server grows under this acquisition. You don't kill the goose that lies the golden eggs. Be a little patient, you may be pleasantly surprised with how well this acquisition goes.

    MySQL employees have the opportunity to be a "Tipping Point" for open source. MySQL employees are currently at the tip of the blade not the bleeding edge. Their vision can be a tremendous change agent for the IT industry. If the MySQL people focus on being great leaders and help define future directions of open source and continue to build new versions of the database open source can count on, then all will be good in the world of open source. Everyone on the Internet: Internet companies such as Google, Yahoo, YouTube, MySpace, bloggers, startup companies, individuals building their first website, hosting companies should all be rooting for the Sun acquisition of MySQL to be successful.

    Friday, January 18, 2008

    Database, Application and Middleware Wars

    The changing dynamics of the IT industry is going to increase in the next year versus slowing down.
    • Oracle's acquisitions in the last few years in the middleware space has the potential to significantly increase it's power to challenge IBM in the middleware space.
    • Oracle's acquisitions in the application space the last few years allows Oracle to go toe to toe with SAP in the business applications space.
    • Sun's backing and support brings a lot of power to MySQL and the web platform of LAMP.
    • The open source world and Internet are changing how people think daily.
    • The innovativeness of the world wide web is creating new companies at an unbelievable rate. The creativity of this space is going to change the world in ways we can't even imagine.
    I almost see this as Oracle having two big aircraft carrier task groups one facing IBM and the other facing SAP. MySQL is like a very fast attack boat that now has a powerful nuclear submarine flying the Sun flag to protect it. Microsoft is another big aircraft carrier task group that everybody is wondering where it is going. The database, application and middleware battles that will occur over the next year is sure to change the face of the IT industry more than we can possibly imagine. This does not even include all the Internet companies like Google, MySpace, YouTube and others that are changing the world everytime we blink. Or maybe more importantly all the new little startups on the Internet that are being born every day.

    I look at this like back in the day when DEC was the second largest computer company in the world and everyone was wondering if they could catch IBM. If back then you had said that in the future a PC company is going to purchase DEC, people would have thought you were crazy. I have the great luxury of traveling in the Oracle and open source worlds. In the Oracle world, I see the incredible power Oracle technology brings to large companies that have complex problems to solve. In the open source world my mind is literally boggled every week with all the incredible, incredible creativity and innovativeness that I see in Internet companies. If you look around everyone can see that rate of change in the world is accelerating. The Internet is spawning new change agents in the world at an exponential rate.

    Thursday, January 17, 2008

    Open Source continuing to change the world

    MySQL by the pure volume of downloads is considered the most popular database for the Internet. MySQL and open source are changing the world as well. The first .com explosion had startup companies throwing a lot of money at traditional hardware and proprietary software. While today, most start ups are running open source solutions like MySQL, Linux, Apache, Perl/PHP, etc. This allows startup companies to have more operational flexibility in their beginning stages. This significantly reduces the startup capital to build the IT infrastructure. By this definition MySQL and open source are helping fuel the world wide economy by allowing companies to have enterprise Internet platforms out of the gate.

    In the last year a number of small and medium sized companies have started using MySQL on projects. With everyone seeing the tremendous success of MySQL in companies like Google and YouTube, you can expect more large companies looking for projects where MySQL is a good fit. With Sun fueling MySQL (solar powered), this should significantly increase the growth of MySQL in the database market. 2008 can expect to see a significant acceleration of open source in the industry.

    Sun has to feel good that they have JavaDB which plays well for smaller databases and now MySQL.

    Wednesday, January 16, 2008

    The Dolphin in the Net, a Great Catch!

    The Dolphin in the Net, a Great Catch!
    Only time will tell, but Sun Microsystems (who said "the NETwork is the computer") was able to capture the dolphin. Sakila the dolphin is the MySQL mascot. Sakila represents power, speed, grace, precision, friendliness and good nature. I believe the open source community would want Sun to help maximize these characteristics and not turn it into a whale. This may turn out to be one of Sun's best acquisitions in a long time. It's interesting that most people think dolphins all look the same and that replication is one of MySQL's most popular features.

    Any good relationship is based on both sides bringing something positive to the table and hopefully each side has positive assets that can counter possible weaknesses in the other. The MySQL acquistion by Sun brings together some strong benefits and assets. Some of the top potential benefits that stand out to me include the capability of making the whole greater than the sum of the parts:
    • MySQL engineers working with Sun engineers is sure to bring new new innovation and strength to the MySQL database server.
    • Sun support, logistics, distribution channels, financial backing definitely will open a lot of doors to big customers for MySQL.
    • The one million plus active instances in the world have the potential of bringing a lot of new customers to Sun.
    • MySQL's disruptive perspective that creates create innovation and ideas in the open source world has a chance to change Sun's culture.
    MySQL's popular open source database could have been purchased by Oracle, Red Hat, HP, IBM or a number of other big companies but Sun may have the most synergy with MySQL. One of MySQL's great assets is its relationship with the open source community. It will be very interesting from an IT industry perspective to see how this new relationship evolves. From a strategic perspective, Sun's capture of the dolphin may be one of the great catches of the year.

    I would highly recommend reading Jonathan Schwartz's blog at http://blogs.sun.com/jonathan.

    Sun to Acquire MySQL - LAMP + MARS

    Sun Microsystems Announces Agreement to Purchase MySQL

    Today, January 16, 2008 Sun Microsystems, Inc. announces it has entered into an agreement to purchase MySQL AB. Sun's distribution channels and support is definitely going to accelerate the growth of MySQL in the database market. MySQL has over 50,000 copies downloaded daily with an estimated total downloads of over 100 million is already the fastest growing database in the Internet market. Combining MySQL with Sun is sure to increase the growth and incredible popularity MySQL is currently encountering. The purchase is for 1 billion dollars, 800 million in cash and 200 million in options. After the announcement Sun stock is up by 10% which is an increase of about 1 billion dollars. Everything is relative. :) The pending purchase is going to be the largest financial transaction for open source. Despite this being an important day for open source, this is just the tip of the iceberg in terms of where open source is going.

    Sun and MySQL - A Change Agent
    Sun's emphasis on meritocracy and MySQL's focus on egalitarianism is sure to bring new innovativeness and ingenuity to the Internet market. The Sun and MySQL cultures have a lot of similarity and this combination is sure to be a change agent. Sun helped change the IT world and replaced Digital Equipment Corporation and forced HP and IBM to change their positions on large big computers being replaced by small powerful computers. MySQL is continuing to change the IT world by providing a strong open source database and has forced proprietary database companies like Oracle, IBM and Microsoft to address the growing popularity of MySQL and open source. Sun currently plays a large role in the server and Java worlds will now play a larger role in IT nfrastructures.

    MySQL Key Component of Web Platform
    The MySQL database is a key component of the web platform along with the LAMP software platform of Linux, Apache, MySQL/memcached and PHP/Perl. With Sun including OpenSolaris, OpenOffice, GlassFish, Java, and NetBeans this is going to increase the power of the web platform that both Sun and MySQL play a key role in. MARS is the MySQL, Apache, Ruby on Rails and Solaris platform. Sun and MySQL have been two of the most innovation companies in the web software platform for the Internet. The combination of MySQL and Sun is sure to help take the web platform to new levels which will benefit large organizations as well as small individual companies.

    The Toy Revolution is Here!
    In the past, some proprietary companies have tried to address the incredible explosion of MySQL's popularity by saying it was a "toy". As stated today, the world had better prepare for the Toy Revolution! Acquisitions today are very dynamic and changing the world. Apple's purchase of Next brought tremendous innovation and creativity to Apple which spearheaded the growth of Apple. Sun's purchase of MySQL has the potential to bring a tremendous amount of new creativity, energy and dynamics to Sun Microsystems.

    Thursday, January 10, 2008

    Excellent Open Source Presentations

    Last night I went to some presentations that were put on by the Chicago chapter of ACM. The two presentations were:

    • An Introduction to Bloom Filters - This presentation focused on choosing the best algorithm to solve a problem. The most familiar trade-off is between storage space and time, but there are more exotic possibilities that can lead to data structures with surprising properties. This presentation discussed Bloom Filters, a probabilistic data structure that efficiently encodes set membership and allows a trade-off between storage space and uncertainty. It was an excellent presentation on how to achieve very high scalabliity with inexpensive hardware using open source.
    • How Open Source Projects Survive Poisonous People -Every open source project runs into people who are selfish, uncooperative, and disrespectful. These people can silently poison the atmosphere of a happy developer community. Come learn how to identify these people and peacefully de-fuse them before they derail your project. Told through a series of (often amusing) real-life anecdotes and experiences.
    These were two absolutely outstanding presentations. The second one was probably the best presentation I've seen in years. Both presentations had tremendous take aways. I would highly recommend attending both of these presentations if they are given again (they will be the audience was asking the presenters if they would give it again at different locations). If this is the type of presentation given at the Chicago ACM chapter I would highly recommend attending a meeting of this organization in the future.

    Wednesday, January 2, 2008

    2007 - MySQL a Year in Review

    2007 has been an interesting year with MySQL. MySQL really seems to have broken out this year. Organizations are absolutely choking on their database and software licensing costs. More and more organizations, large and small are now recognizing MySQL databases as a viable solution for database projects.

    If MySQL can be a solution for a database project, it can provide a lot of flexibility for organizations. Leading managers are looking at more ways to be competitive in today's global markets. A number of the largest Internet websites are using MySQL to provide extremely fast reliable Internet solutions. These success stories have more IT managers asking what MySQL can do for them. A great success story can be found at:
    http://itc.conversationsnetwork.org/shows/detail3299.html

    In 2007, more than any year open source solutions have taken an exponential leap in use and acceptance in the market place. In the last year I've gone into some of the largest companies in the U.S. and seen an explosion of MySQL databases. In 2008, I expect to see the growth of open source solutions increase in use and acceptance. My top three reasons I see a significant increase in MySQL databases for 2008:
    1. IT managers beginning to think out of the box and realizing how open source can offer greater flexibility in choosing software solutions.
    2. Industry acceptance of open source solutions in the enterprise.
    3. Popularity of MySQL version 5 features.
    The large vendors can no longer ignore the growing popularity of open source and MySQL. 2007 has seen large vendor companies purchasing open source products. It's funny, I've seen a few blogs predict gloom and doom for MySQL because Oracle purchased InnoDB and IBM purchased SolidDB. I see the exact opposite. The purchases of popular storage engines used by MySQL shows the growing popularity and use of MySQL can not be ignored by large vendor companies. Their purchases bring more light and industry awareness of popular storage engines used by MySQL.

    I predict InnoDB and SolidDB storage engines will be used more than ever in MySQL databases. As MySQL 6.0 moves towards GA, you will see the Falcon storage engine increase in interest and popularity with it being the next generation in transactional storage engines for MySQL.

    The growth of open source is going to be very interesting to watch in 2008. As Oracle, Microsoft and IBM, BEA, etc. add more and more features to their products and increase their prices, open source products grow in popularity and marketshare at almost the same pace. The growth of MySpace, YouTube, MySQL, etc. is continuing to demonstrate the incredible dynamics of the Internet and how the use of open source is continuing to change our IT industry. I don't work with all open source products but the following are products I work with and see them becoming more popular than ever before. Popular open source solutions that I predict will continue to grow in 2008 include:
    • MySQL
    • Apache
    • Apache Tomcat
    • JBoss
    • Eclipse
    • Spring